With President Joe Biden’s new pardon policy, gay military veterans are left contemplating the implications on their pre-Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell (DADT) service records. This policy, enacted in 1993 and repealed in 2011, prohibited military personnel from openly identifying as LGBTQ+. Although DADT was lifted over a decade ago, many veterans continue to face the consequences of their pre-DADT service records.
Implications for Veterans
The new pardon policy, which took effect on St. Patrick’s Day 2023, includes not only individual pardons but also a mass commutation of sentences related to federal marijuana offenses. However, there is currently no clear guidance on how this policy applies to military veterans and their pre-DADT service records. Many fear that coming forward with their past sexual orientation or gender identity could lead to negative consequences, such as dishonorable discharge, loss of benefits, or even legal action.
Reactions from Advocacy Groups
LGBTQ+ advocacy groups have reacted with a mix of optimism and caution. The American Military Partner Association (AMPA) has expressed hope that the pardon policy may eventually lead to expungement or sealing of military records related to discharges under DADT. However, they also emphasize the need for explicit policy changes to protect veterans’ privacy and prevent potential retaliation.
The Veterans Legal Support Program
One organization working to address these concerns is the Veterans Legal Support (VLS) program. Established in 2016, VLS provides free legal assistance to veterans seeking to correct military records or reinstate benefits lost due to their sexual orientation or gender identity. With the new pardon policy in place, VLS hopes to expand its services and support a larger number of veterans. However, they recognize that there is still much work to be done in terms of policy changes and public awareness.
Moving Forward
As the implications of Biden’s pardon policy continue to unfold, gay military veterans remain uncertain about what lies ahead. Some are hesitant to come forward due to fear of negative consequences, while others feel that the time has come for them to reclaim their dignity and benefits. Ultimately, it will take a combination of legal changes, advocacy efforts, and public awareness to ensure that these veterans receive the support they deserve.
I. Introduction
Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell (DADT), a military policy that prohibited openly gay, lesbian, and bisexual individuals from serving in the United States Armed Forces, has left a significant mark on American history.
Historical Context
The policy was implemented on December 21, 1993, under President Bill Clinton, following a contentious political battle. DADT mandated that military personnel could not disclose their sexual orientation nor ask about the sexual orientation of their fellow servicemembers. This policy, however, did not prevent investigations into suspected gay or lesbian individuals, leading to numerous discharges and a culture of secrecy and fear within the military ranks.
Impact
The impact of DADT was far-reaching, causing emotional distress, financial hardship, and professional limitations for countless gay military personnel. Thousands were discharged under the policy, often facing significant challenges in finding employment and securing health benefits due to the stigma attached to their sexual orientation.
Repeal in 2011
Following years of advocacy and a growing consensus that the policy was discriminatory, DADT was formally repealed on September 20, 2011, when President Barack Obama signed a bill to end the policy. The repeal was met with relief and celebration by many in the LGBTQ+ community, signifying a significant step forward for inclusion and equality in the military.
Importance of Understanding the Implications of Biden’s New Pardon Policy for Gay Military Veterans
With the recent announcement by President Joe Biden granting pardons to thousands of individuals convicted under the old marijuana laws, a question arises regarding its implications for gay military veterans discharged under DADT. While these pardons do not directly apply to the former policy, it underscores a critical issue: the ongoing challenges faced by many gay veterans in accessing military benefits and services due to their past discharges.
Military Benefits and Services
Many gay veterans are still excluded from certain military benefits, such as disability compensation, health care, and veteran status due to their discharges under DADT. These exclusions are the result of the “honorable” or “general under honorable conditions” characterization that accompanied many discharges under DADT.
Implications of Biden’s Pardon Policy
Although the pardons do not address this issue directly, they may pave the way for further discussions and potential legislative efforts aimed at ensuring equal access to military benefits and services for all veterans, regardless of their sexual orientation. The Biden Administration’s commitment to social justice issues could potentially lead to significant progress in this area.
Background on Biden’s New Pardon Policy
On January 20, 2021, President Joe Biden signed an executive order on pardons and commutations, marking a significant shift in criminal justice reform. This order, which aims to restore the power of clemency to its original intent, merits considerable attention. It empowers the Department of Justice (DOJ) to identify candidates for pardons and commutations who deserve a second chance, regardless of the crime or sentence.
President Biden’s executive order on pardons and commutations:
Purpose and significance of the order: President Biden’s executive order aims to correct historical injustices by removing barriers for people who have paid their debt to society. It also seeks to address racial and ethnic disparities within the criminal justice system. By extending pardon eligibility to state and federal crimes, the order demonstrates a commitment to inclusivity.
The impact on military veterans, especially those discharged under DADT:
Explanation of the dishonorable and other-than-honorable discharge statuses: Military personnel can be separated from the service with various types of discharges, including honorable and dishonorable. Dishonorable discharges are given to service members who violated major laws or regulations, while other-than-honorable (OTH) discharges are given for less serious offenses. Those with OTH or dishonorable discharges are often subjected to lifelong consequences that hinder their ability to rebuild their lives.
Disproportionate effect on LGBTQ+ veterans:
Background of DADT (Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell): Until 2011, the US military’s “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” (DADT) policy prohibited openly LGBTQ+ individuals from serving in the armed forces. Those discovered to be LGBTQ+ risked being discharged under dishonorable or other-than-honorable conditions, despite having otherwise exemplary records.
2.Impact of DADT
a. Stigma and discrimination: The repeal of DADT did not immediately expunge the records or discharge statuses of those affected by it, leaving many veterans with the stigma and discrimination of a dishonorable or OTH discharge.
2.Lack of support
b. Limited access to benefits: Due to their discharge statuses, LGBTQ+ veterans often face challenges in accessing VA healthcare and other military-related benefits.
2.Barriers to employment
c. Difficulty in finding work: A dishonorable or OTH discharge can prevent veterans from obtaining employment, making it challenging for them to rebuild their lives and provide for themselves and their families.
Significance of Biden’s pardon policy for LGBTQ+ veterans:
a. Providing relief and closure: By extending clemency to crimes committed during military service, including those related to discharge statuses under DADT, the Biden administration aims to provide relief and closure to thousands of LGBTQ+ veterans who were unjustly punished for their sexual orientation.
I The Legal Basis for Biden’s Pardon Policy and its Application to DADS Cases
The pardon power, a prerogative granted to the President of the United States by Article II, Section 2 of the U.S. Constitution, allows the executive branch to grant clemency and commutations to individuals convicted of federal crimes. This power, which extends back to the founding era, has evolved significantly throughout history, reflecting shifting societal values and political priorities.
Overview of pardon power and its limitations
Historical context and development: The Magna Carta, signed in 1215, marked the first recorded instance of a monarch granting a pardon. By the time the U.S. Constitution was drafted in 1787, the concept of executive clemency had become well-established. George Washington granted several pardons during his presidency, and the power continued to be used sparingly but regularly throughout American history. In recent decades, however, presidents have increasingly relied on the Department of Justice to recommend pardons based on legal analyses and case-by-case merits.
Current interpretations and debates:
The pardon power remains a subject of ongoing debate, with some arguing that it is an absolute power granted to the president, while others contend that it is subject to certain checks and balances. For instance, some scholars have suggested that a pardon cannot be granted if it violates the U.S. Constitution or infringes upon Congress’s legislative authority. Additionally, there is ongoing discussion about whether a pardon can be granted prospectively – before a person has been convicted or charged with a crime.
The application of Biden’s pardon policy to DADT cases
Precedents: Clinton’s DOMA pardons and WWII-era discharges: In the late 1990s, President Bill Clinton granted pardons to several hundred individuals convicted of crimes related to consensual homosexual conduct, citing concerns about the disproportionate impact of these laws on LGBTQ+ communities. More recently, in 2017, a coalition of veterans sought pardons for discharges under “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” (DADT), arguing that these discharges constituted discrimination based on sexual orientation.
Legal reasoning: Discrimination as a basis for pardon consideration:
President Biden’s recent announcement that his administration would review DADT discharges for potential pardons reflects this historical context and ongoing debates about the pardon power’s reach. By focusing on discrimination as a basis for pardon consideration, Biden is acknowledging that past policies – including DADT – have unfairly targeted marginalized communities and inflicted harm. This approach could pave the way for future presidents to grant clemency based on similar considerations, such as racial or gender-based discrimination.
Practical Implications of Biden’s Pardon Policy for Gay Military Veterans
Practical Implications of President Joe Biden’s pardon policy hold significant meaning for gay military veterans, who were once discharged under Don't Ask, Don't Tell (DADT) and received dishonorable or other-than-honorable discharges as a result of their sexual orientation. Here’s how this policy change might impact their lives in various aspects:
Eligibility and application process
Determining eligibility: To be considered for a pardon, veterans must have received a dishonorable or other-than-honorable discharge due to their sexual orientation during the period when DADT was in effect. It is crucial to note that not all individuals with these types of discharges will automatically be granted a pardon. Instead, each application will be reviewed on a case-by-case basis.
Possible outcomes:
Military benefits and entitlements:
If successful, a pardon could lead to the restoration of military benefits for these veterans. These benefits include access to VA healthcare, education assistance, and retirement pay.
Employment opportunities and rights:
A pardon might help to improve employment opportunities for these veterans, as it could change the discharge status on their military records. This can be particularly important when applying for federal jobs or other positions that require a clean record. Additionally, the pardon could help to restore certain civilian licenses and certifications that were revoked due to their military discharge status.
Psychological effects and personal recognition:
A pardon could provide a measure of closure and personal recognition for veterans who have carried the burden of a dishonorable or other-than-honorable discharge for years. This acknowledgment of their service and sacrifice could contribute to a positive impact on their mental health and overall wellbeing.
Potential challenges:
Legal grounds for contesting denial decisions:
It’s important to recognize that not every application will be granted a pardon. Veterans may challenge denial decisions by seeking legal representation and exploring the potential grounds for contesting these decisions based on the circumstances surrounding their discharge and the application process.
Advocacy and support networks:
Organizations such as the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) and veterans’ advocacy groups have already expressed their support for this policy change. These groups can provide valuable guidance, resources, and assistance throughout the application process to help ensure the best possible outcome for eligible veterans.
Conclusion
President Biden’s pardon policy, specifically for gay military veterans, holds immense significance as it represents an essential step towards repairing past injustices and healing wounds inflicted by the military’s discriminatory policies against LGBTQ+ individuals. (
1.
) The Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell policy, which prohibited openly gay individuals from serving in the military between 1993 and 2011, led to thousands of dismissals and dishonorable discharges. Biden’s pardons serve as a symbolic gesture of acknowledgement and reconciliation for these veterans, who were unjustly punished based on their sexual orientation. (
1.1.
) Furthermore, this policy change demonstrates a commitment to acknowledging the contributions of LGBTQ+ veterans, whose service and dedication to their country should never be questioned or overlooked because of who they love. (
1.2.
)
Moving forward, it’s crucial to recognize that ongoing efforts are necessary to address military discrimination and create a more inclusive society for all veterans. (
2.
) Although the repeal of Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell in 2011 marked a significant milestone towards equality within the military, there is still work to be done to ensure that all veterans are treated fairly and equitably. This may include:
Addressing the mental health challenges faced by LGBTQ+ veterans due to past discrimination and stigma
Providing resources to help LGBTQ+ veterans reintegrate into society after their military service and transition back to civilian life
Advocating for policies that promote a more inclusive military culture, such as anti-discrimination legislation and increasing awareness of LGBTQ+ issues within the armed forces
In conclusion, while Biden’s pardon policy marks an essential milestone in repairing past injustices towards gay military veterans and acknowledging their contributions to our society, there is still much work to be done. By focusing on ongoing efforts to address military discrimination and create a more inclusive society for all veterans, we can ensure that no one is left behind or overlooked based on their sexual orientation. (
2.1.
) This commitment to equality and inclusion not only benefits individual veterans but also strengthens our military as a whole, making it a more resilient and diverse force capable of facing the challenges of the future. (
2.2.
)
