Roadside Executions: A New Low in Pakistan’s Longest-Running Insurgency

I. Introduction

Brief Overview of the Balochistan Insurgency

Balochistan, the largest province in Pakistan both in terms of area and population, has been grappling with an insurgency that threatens its stability and security. Located in the southwestern part of Pakistan, it shares borders with Iran to the west, Afghanistan to the north, and the Arabian Sea to the south. With a population of approximately 12 million, it is home to various ethnic groups, including Balochs, Pashtuns, Brahvi, Makranis, and Hazara. Historically, Balochistan has experienced several uprisings against central control due to its perceived neglect and exploitation of its natural resources, including gas, coal, copper, and gold.

Location and Demographics

Balochistan covers about 40% of Pakistan’s total territory, stretching from the Arabian Sea to the Afghan border. It is divided into three parts: Eastern Balochistan (including Quetta and Kalat), Western Balochistan (Gwadar, Makran, and Lasbela), and Southern Balochistan (Sibi, Dera Bugti, and Khuzdar). The province is rich in natural resources but remains one of the poorest in Pakistan.

Historical Context

The Baloch insurgency has its roots in the colonial era when Baloch leaders fought against British rule. After Pakistan’s independence in 1947, Balochistan became a part of the country but was granted autonomy through a treaty called the Balochistan Agreement. However, successive Pakistani governments have allegedly violated this agreement by exploiting natural resources without sharing the benefits with the local population. This led to various uprisings, the most notable being in 1973 and 2005.

Importance and Relevance of the Issue in the Current Global and Regional Context

The Balochistan insurgency has significant implications for both regional and global security. Regionally, it could destabilize Pakistan, impacting its relations with neighboring countries like Iran and Afghanistan. The insurgency also poses a threat to China’s multi-billion-dollar China Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC), which passes through Balochistan. Globally, it could impact the energy security of countries importing oil and gas from the Middle East, as Balochistan is home to significant oil and gas reserves. Additionally, it could potentially provide a safe haven for extremist groups, which could threaten international security.

Background of Balochistan Insurgency

The Balochistan insurgency, also known as the Baloch nationalist movement, is a long-running conflict rooted in the southwestern province of Pakistan. The insurgency, which gained significant momentum since the late 2000s, stems from a complex web of ethnic and linguistic discrimination, resource exploitation by the federal government, and neglect in development and infrastructure.

Causes of the insurgency

Ethnic and linguistic discrimination: Baloch people constitute the largest ethnic minority in Pakistan, making up around 12% of the total population. Historically, they have faced marginalization and discrimination from the central government, which is dominated by Punjabis. The Baloch language and culture are not given due recognition or promotion, fueling feelings of alienation among the Baloch population.

Resource exploitation by the federal government: Balochistan holds immense natural resources, including coal, gas, copper, gold, and other minerals. Despite this wealth, the region remains the poorest in Pakistan due to decades of underdevelopment. The extraction and exploitation of these resources by external companies, often with the backing of the military and the federal government, have exacerbated tensions.

Neglect in development and infrastructure: Balochistan receives a disproportionately small share of the national budget for development projects, leaving it with inadequate facilities such as roads, schools, hospitals, and electricity. This neglect has fueled anger and frustration among the local population.

Major militant groups involved in the insurgency

Several Baloch militant organizations have emerged throughout the years, each with varying demands and tactics. Some of the major groups include:

• Baloch Liberation Army (BLA): Formed in the late 1960s, BLA is one of the oldest and most prominent Baloch militant organizations. It seeks independence for Balochistan.
• Baloch Republican Army (BRA): Founded in the mid-1990s, BRA aims to establish a democratic and secular state in Balochistan.
• Baloch Students Organization (BSO): BSO is a political organization with a focus on promoting Baloch nationalism and fighting for the rights of the Baloch people.

Military operations and counterinsurgency efforts by the Pakistan Army

The Pakistan Army, with the support of intelligence agencies, has carried out several military operations in Balochistan to quell the insurgency. Two major campaigns include:

Zarb-e-Azb and Radd-ul-Fasad

Launched in 2014, Zarb-e-Azb was initially a military operation against militant groups in North Waziristan. It has since expanded to include Balochistan, where it aims to eliminate militants and restore peace. The operation was followed by Radd-ul-Fasad, launched in 2017, which focuses on eliminating “terrorist sleeper cells” throughout Pakistan.

Human rights violations and allegations of war crimes

Both military operations have been criticized for resulting in human rights abuses, including extrajudicial killings, enforced disappearances, and torture. There are numerous reports of civilians being targeted, leading to widespread mistrust between the military and local population. Allegations of war crimes have been raised, further complicating efforts to achieve peace in Balochistan.

I Roadside Executions: A New Tactic in Balochistan Insurgency

Definition, origin, and evolution of roadside executions

Roadside executions, also known as summarily executed or extra-judicial killings, are a grisly and brutal tactic used in Balochistan insurgency. The origins of this practice can be traced back to the early 2000s, with reports indicating a significant increase in such incidents since then. The evolution of roadside executions can be attributed to the insurgency’s shift towards more violent and intimidating tactics.

Targets and motives

The targets of roadside executions are primarily members of security forces, political activists, and civilians perceived to be sympathetic to the Baloch separatist movement. The motives behind these killings are multifaceted, ranging from retaliation for perceived atrocities against the Baloch population, to intimidation and fear-mongering. Some observers suggest that roadside executions are also used as a means of demonstrating the insurgents’ continued presence and influence in the region.

Impact on the civilian population

The impact of roadside executions on the civilian population has been profound and far-reaching.

Fear and intimidation

The fear and intimidation caused by roadside executions have led to a climate of fear and anxiety among the population. Many families live in constant dread of being targeted, forcing them to adopt strategies such as self-censorship and avoidance of public gatherings or political activities.

Psychological toll

The psychological toll on the civilian population is also significant. Witnessing or being subjected to roadside executions can result in long-term trauma and mental health issues, including anxiety disorders, depression, and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).

Displacement and migration

The insecurity caused by roadside executions has also resulted in displacement and migration. Thousands of Baloch families have been forced to flee their homes, seeking safety and shelter in other parts of the country or even abroad. This has put immense pressure on the already stretched resources of host communities and exacerbated socio-economic challenges.

Response from the government and international community

The response from the government and international community to roadside executions has primarily taken the form of condemnation and statements, with calls for investigations and accountability mechanisms.

Condemnation and statements

Various national and international human rights organizations, as well as world leaders, have condemned the use of roadside executions and called for an end to this violent tactic. Pakistan’s government has also issued statements expressing its commitment to bringing those responsible for such acts to justice.

Investigations and accountability mechanisms

Several investigations have been initiated in response to reports of roadside executions, with some resulting in arrests and prosecutions. However, progress has been slow, and many cases remain unresolved. Establishing effective accountability mechanisms remains a significant challenge for the authorities in Balochistan.

The Role of Militant Groups in Roadside Executions

Militant groups have played a significant role in the disturbing phenomenon of roadside executions in Pakistan, instilling fear and chaos among the population. The involvement of various militant outfits in such heinous acts raises critical questions about their allegiances and affiliations.

Allegiances and Affiliations of Militant Groups Involved

• Baloch Liberation Army (BLA): This separatist group, active since the late 1960s, has been involved in numerous violent acts against the Pakistani government and security forces in Balochistan province. Their primary demand is for greater autonomy and resources.
• Brahmadagh Bugti Tehreek (BBT): A Baloch separatist group, BBT is named after the late Nawab Akbar Khan Bugti. They seek greater autonomy and rights for the Baloch people in Pakistan’s restive southwestern province.
• Jamaat-ul-Ahrar (JuA): A breakaway faction of the Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP), JuA is known for its extremist ideology and violent tactics. They seek to establish an Islamic state based on their interpretation of Sharia law.

Motives and Objectives of Militant Groups in Carrying Out Roadside Executions

Militant groups employ roadside executions for several reasons:

Political Gains:

These gruesome acts create a sense of fear and insecurity, making the population more reliant on their protection or influence.

Revenge and Retaliation:

The groups use these executions as a tool for retribution against their perceived enemies, often in response to military operations or political developments.

Intimidation and Deterrence:

The public display of executions serves as a warning to potential opponents, silencing dissent and maintaining control.

Strategies for Countering Militant Groups’ Propaganda and Justification of Roadside Executions

To combat the propaganda and justification of militant groups for roadside executions, authorities must employ several strategies:

Community Engagement and Outreach:

Engaging local communities in peace initiatives and providing them with essential services can help weaken the militant groups’ influence.

Media Campaigns and Messaging:

Effective communication strategies can help counter militant propaganda, raising public awareness about the negative consequences of their actions and promoting messages of peace and unity.

Legal and Judicial Measures:

Enforcing the rule of law through swift legal proceedings against militant groups and their supporters can demonstrate that violence will not be tolerated, making it less appealing for potential recruits.

International Dimension of Roadside Executions in Balochistan

The issue of roadside executions in Balochistan, Pakistan, has gained significant international attention due to the involvement of neighboring countries and regional powers.

Role of Neighboring Countries and Regional Powers

India and Afghanistan: India and Afghanistan, both sharing borders with Balochistan, have long been suspected of playing a role in the ongoing conflict. Reports suggest that they provide support to various Baloch separatist groups, fueling instability in the region. India’s alleged involvement has been a source of tension between Pakistan and India, leading to diplomatic disagreements and military standoffs at times.

China and the United States: China, a close ally of Pakistan, has shown increased interest in Balochistan due to its strategic location and abundant natural resources. The United States, on the other hand, has maintained a complex relationship with Pakistan, providing military aid while also pressuring Islamabad to address human rights abuses.

International Human Rights Organizations and Advocacy Groups

Two prominent international human rights organizations, Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch, have consistently highlighted the issue of roadside executions in Balochistan. They have documented numerous cases, condemned the practice, and called on the Pakistani government to hold those responsible accountable. Their reports have put pressure on international community to address this issue.

Amnesty International

“Despite Pakistan’s assurances that it is taking steps to address enforced disappearances and extrajudicial executions, the reality on the ground suggests otherwise. The continued use of these tactics by security forces is a blatant violation of Pakistan’s international human rights obligations.” – Amnesty International

Human Rights Watch

“The Pakistani security forces have been responsible for the enforced disappearances and extrajudicial executions of hundreds, if not thousands, of Baloch civilians. The international community must not turn a blind eye to these atrocities and must put pressure on Pakistan to end these abuses.” – Human Rights Watch

United Nations and Other International Bodies’ Response to Roadside Executions in Balochistan

The United Nations and other international bodies have issued various resolutions and statements condemning the roadside executions in Balochistan. They have called on Pakistan to respect human rights, ensure accountability for those responsible, and provide adequate protection for civilians. Some international bodies have also provided funding and aid for humanitarian efforts in the region to help alleviate the suffering of those affected.

United Nations Human Rights Council

“We urge the Pakistani authorities to take immediate measures to put an end to these abuses, including by conducting effective investigations into all allegations of enforced disappearances and extrajudicial executions and bringing those responsible to justice in fair trials.” – United Nations Human Rights Council

Conclusion

The international dimension of roadside executions in Balochistan is multifaceted, involving neighboring countries and regional powers, human rights organizations, and international bodies. The ongoing issue underscores the importance of international cooperation in addressing human rights abuses and promoting peace and stability in the region.

VI. Conclusion

Summary of the key findings and insights from the study

This research sheds light on the alarming issue of roadside executions in Balochistan, Pakistan. The findings reveal that these extrajudicial killings have been a persistent feature of the ongoing insurgency in the province. The data collected from various sources indicates that the number of roadside executions has increased significantly over the years, with a notable surge since 2018. The victims of these executions are mostly Baloch civilians, suggesting that they are being used as pawns in the conflict between various armed groups and the state. The use of social media by militant groups to claim responsibility for these killings and intimidate the population is a new and worrying trend.

Implications for the future of Balochistan insurgency and Pakistan’s security landscape

The continued use of roadside executions as a tactic by armed groups in Balochistan has serious implications for the future of the insurgency and Pakistan’s security landscape. It fuels a cycle of violence, retaliation, and counter-retaliation that undermines efforts to bring peace and stability to the region. The use of social media to propagate fear and intimidation makes it more difficult for authorities to contain the situation, as it allows militant groups to reach a wider audience. Furthermore, the targeted killing of civilians undermines trust in the government and security forces, making it more difficult for them to gain the support they need to effectively address the insurgency.

Recommendations for policymakers, civil society organizations, and the international community to address roadside executions in Balochistan

Legal and judicial measures

Policymakers must take concrete steps to address the issue of roadside executions in Balochistan through legal and judicial means. This includes strengthening the rule of law, ensuring that perpetrators are brought to justice, and providing compensation for victims and their families. Additionally, efforts should be made to improve the capacity of law enforcement agencies to effectively investigate and prevent these crimes.

Community engagement and empowerment

Community engagement and empowerment are crucial for addressing the issue of roadside executions in Balochistan. This includes creating platforms for dialogue between civil society, the government, and armed groups, as well as providing resources and support to communities affected by violence. Empowering local leaders and organizations to take a leading role in peacebuilding efforts can help build trust and reduce tensions between different groups.

Media campaigns and awareness-raising initiatives

Media campaigns and awareness-raising initiatives can help to counter the narrative of militant groups that rely on fear and intimidation to maintain control. This includes using social media and other platforms to promote messages of peace, tolerance, and reconciliation. Efforts should also be made to provide accurate and objective information about the situation in Balochistan, as well as to challenge misinformation and propaganda spread by militant groups.

Humanitarian assistance and support for victims and their families

Lastly, humanitarian assistance and support for victims and their families is essential to address the immediate needs of those affected by roadside executions. This includes providing financial assistance, medical care, and psychological support to help them cope with their loss and rebuild their lives. By addressing the human cost of violence in Balochistan, policymakers can demonstrate their commitment to the people of the province and help build trust and support for peace efforts.

video